Ethics is the practice of describing, analysing, and evaluating what is right and wrong, good and bad, or fair or unfair in human conduct.
Plain Ethics is an approach to ethics that is based on the use of simple concepts and models for describing, analysing, and evaluating ethical conduct, as well as design and reviewing arrangements governing ethical conduct. It helps people explain the concepts and values they use in relation to ethical conduct and give reasons for their judgements and choices.
Plain Ethics can be used with different ethical theories. It is designed to provide a framework accommodating value-based, duty-based, or consequence-based theories.
While the examples and tools presented in this website focus on organisational contexts, the ideas can be used in many settings.
Purpose
Plain Ethics aims to help people talk and reflect about ethical conduct in an analytical and critical way, while remaining accessible. It offers a framework and a set of tools based on clear, simple concepts.
Objectives
Plain Ethics aims to help you:
- describe conduct and situations from an ethical perspective in terms that minimise ambiguities and misunderstandings;
- analyse how expectations to ethical conduct are articulated and embedded in arrangements;
- review the reasons behing judgements, choices, and responses relating to ethical conduct, systematically taking into account the circumstances.
Concepts and description
A key assumption of Plain Ethics is that the same situation can be described in different ways. The concepts we use shape what we are saying about it, with consequences for how we assess it and, ultimately, if a response is required, what we decide to do. Plain Ethics makes the concepts used and their relationships explicit so that you can fully understand the descriptions on which your judgements depend.
For example (a very simple one), someone who withholds information under a manager's instruction is both withholding information and following an instruction.
The approach focuses on carefully describing situations in ways that others can understand to intiate robust decisions and action. While it is in a sense 'front-loaded' by insisting on a thorough description of the situation, the appreciation of the situation remains an ongoing requirement throughout the evaluation.
Method
The framework brings together a small set of principles, a pool of concepts and their connections, and shows how they form models to describe and analyse situations. The principles guide you in applying the models and tools to a given situation. Concepts identify key elements that make up a situation to which they apply. Connections show how these elements relate to each other to form models that will enable users to evaluate conduct or design arrangements to enable ethical conduct.
We explain each concept through a short definition and a model. The model identifies the elements and relationships involved in an action or situation that a sentence pattern or diagram makes explicit.
For example, a promise:
Someone commits to someone that they will do or refrain from doing something.
This identifies who makes the promise, to whom, and what they undertake to do or refrain from doing.
This approach draws on J. L. Austin's work on ordinary language and speech acts, and on Charles J. Fillmore's account of semantic frames. FrameNet defines a frame as “a description of a type of event, relation, or entity and the participants in it”.
The open places (stand-ins like 'someone', 'something') in a sentence pattern show which particulars need to be identified in a given situation.
To visualise the models used in Plain Ethics, we draw simple diagrams with nodes (also called vertices) and connections (also called edges). Nodes represent the elements of a model, e.g., a person or an action. Connections show how these elements relate to each other, e.g., someone has a duty to do something. Connections will have an arrow to indicate a direction where appropriate, e.g., one person makes a promise to another. These diagrams complement sentence patterns by helping you describe a situation and analyse its structure.
In Plain Ethics, we look at concepts through the situations in which people use them, identifying the participants, actions and relationships involved.
You can use these structures to analyse a situation into key elements and connections, then combine them into models to describe more complex arrangements or courses of action. This can assist with both evaluating existing courses of action and developing new ones.
For example, a promise is linked with what the person subsequently does, how another person relies on it, when we would say it has been broken, and the possible response in case it is broken.
In Plain Ethics, a key insight is that assessing what someone did and assessing their responsibility are different questions. A justification gives good reasons for doing the act. An excuse reduces or removes a person's responsibility for an act that is deemed wrong or in some respect inappropriate. Anwering questions relating to what was done and responsibility may require paying attention to the person's intentions, the knowledge that was available to them at the time, the available courses of action, other people's contributions, and broadly the circumstances in which the person acted. Plain Ethics' key contribution is to provide a framework to assist with answering these questions. You will still need to think through a situation and exercise judgement. It offers a systematic, but flexible and accessible, way of doing so.
For acts performed through a procedure, such as authorising a payment or making an appointment, we examine whether the procedure exists and is accepted, who is entitled to act, and whether the circumstances are appropriate. We examine whether the procedure is carried out correctly and completely, whether participants have the thoughts, feelings or intentions it requires, and whether they subsequently act as it requires.
Cases help us examine descriptions, compare situations, and develop an account of what matters. We consider good conduct, failures, and differences that affect the assessment. Changing a feature, such as what someone knew or the choices available to them, helps explain why it matters to the judgement.
Importance
Ethical judgements influence how people are treated, what organisations require of them, and how their conduct is recognised or challenged. In organisations, roles, instructions, rewards, resources, and working practices affect the choices people face and what they do.
People who agree that something was wrong can still disagree about why it happened and what should be done. Plain Ethics connects an examination of conduct with an examination of responses. You identify what a response is intended to achieve, who should act, and why it is appropriate. Responses include recognising good conduct, giving an explanation, apologising, making amends, and changing a practice or arrangement.
Benefits
Plain Ethics supports analytical thinking, shared understanding, and reflection on professional practice.
Analytical and critical thinking
The framework provides a method for clarifying concepts, making distinctions, examining relationships, and comparing alternatives. These activities are central to critical thinking. The method helps you identify implicit or missing assumptions, analyse conduct and evaluate reasons.
Shared understanding
Simple, clear concepts provide a common and accessible starting point for discussion. The concepts provided help people clarify what they mean, check how expressions apply to a particular situation, and identify the grounds of agreement or disagreement.
Reflective practice
The framework provides simple models for examining professional practice. You can use these models to describe familiar situations, make your assumptions explicit and compare different professional approaches on that basis.
An open-minded approach
The framework encourages you to consider alternative descriptions and situations, examine objections and revise your judgements in light of the reasons presented.
Taken together, the framework and associated tools provide a practical basis for developing judgement in ethics.
Using the approach
We encourage you to apply Plain Ethics to situations that matter to you professionally or otherwise. Use it to describe what happened or what should be done, and explain the reasons for your judgement, response, or proposed arrangement.