Framework sections

The framework / 07

Evaluating conduct

Evaluating conduct involves giving reasons for a judgement about what someone did. This model is based on two aspects of conduct, responsibility and reprehensibility, and looks at one while holding the other one fixed. For example, we all agree that the conduct was wrong and had damaging consequences for the organisation, but how responsible is the person? This model helps you identify the type of situation you find yourself in (is there agreement on the responsibility, reprehensibility, or none?), and focus on the questions that matter in the situation.

This section makes explicit some of the assessments that were made in describing what someone did. In that section, you used a simple pattern (X did A) to describe what someone did while challenging that description through some questions about the person, doing, and specific action in the description. This section combines those challenges into a general evaluation of the conduct: this evaluation can excuse, aggravate, condemn, or justify the conduct as described.

Starting from an account of what someone did, Evaluate conduct distinguishes four forms of assessment:

How to read the model

The two points represent the person and what was done. Read the arrow from left to right: the person did the action.

The circle marks the reference: what is taken as given for the question. The other point is the emphasis: what is being assessed.

In condemnation and justification, the person’s responsibility is taken as given, and the assessment is of what was done. In aggravation and excuse, what was done is taken as objectionable, and the assessment is of the person’s responsibility. Remember that each quadrant identifies questions that matter in the situation: it does not gives a ready-made answer.

Condemnation

ReferencePerson EmphasisWhat was done

What makes what was done wrong or objectionable in these circumstances?

Aggravation

EmphasisPerson ReferenceWhat was done

What strengthens the person’s responsibility for what was done?

Justification

ReferencePerson EmphasisWhat was done

What makes what was done right, permissible, or reasonable despite the objection?

Excuse

EmphasisPerson ReferenceWhat was done

What reduces or removes the person’s responsibility for what was done?

A justification responds to the reprehensibility of the conduct. An excuse accepts that the conduct (or consequences) is untoward, but qualifies the person’s responsibility. These distinctions matter when deciding how to respond to the conduct.