Framework sections

The framework / 09

Assessing effectiveness of arrangements for expected conduct

Assessing arrangements for expected conduct examines how they are adopted and applied, and whether they achieve their intended purpose. Identify the arrangement, the conduct it calls for, and the people and circumstances concerned.

Adoption and application

Some acts depend on an accepted procedure or practice. Adopting a code by resolution, appointing someone to a role, and making a commitment each have requirements for the act to be performed. For such acts, examine:

1. The arrangement exists

Description

There is an arrangement with a particular conventional effect: following it counts as performing a particular act.

Typical failure

The purported arrangement does not exist.

2. The arrangement is accepted

Description

The arrangement is accepted within the organisation.

Typical failure

The arrangement exists but is not accepted.

3. The participants and circumstances are appropriate

Description

The participants, their capacities, and the circumstances are appropriate for using the arrangement.

Typical failure

The arrangement is invoked by inappropriate people or in inappropriate circumstances.

4. The arrangement is carried out correctly

Description

The participants implement the arrangement in the required manner.

Typical failure

The arrangement is implemented incorrectly.

5. All required steps are completed

Description

All parts required to complete the act are performed.

Typical failure

The arrangement is left incomplete.

6. The participants have the required thoughts, feelings, or intentions

Description

The participants have whatever thoughts, feelings, or intentions the procedure requires.

Typical failure

A required attitude is absent.

7. The participants carry out the required subsequent conduct

Description

After implementing the arrangement, the participants act as it requires them to.

Typical failure

The required subsequent conduct does not occur.

Failures concerning the arrangement’s existence, acceptance, applicability, or execution can prevent the act from being accomplished. Missing attitudes or a failure to act as subsequently required can leave the act accomplished but defective. A code can be properly adopted and then disregarded. A commitment can be made without the intention to fulfil it. Identify the particular failure and its grounds.

Use these questions where the act has such requirements. For resources, support, or working conditions, examine what is provided and whether it enables the expected conduct.

Purpose and results

Specify what the arrangement is intended to achieve, what results are expected, and why. Compare these with what happens over a stated period. Establish the connection between the arrangement and the results, including other conditions and people’s contributions.

Example: consultation and roster decisions

A consultation requirement may be correctly introduced and followed, yet the information gathered may be ignored when rosters are decided. Examine what consultation involved, what was done with the information, and how the decisions affected staff.

Assess effectiveness examines these matters through the seven conditions above. Under condition 1, explain the point or purpose of the arrangement. Under condition 7, compare the expected subsequent conduct and results with what actually occurs.

Reconsidering the arrangements

Use the findings to identify what needs reconsideration: the expected conduct, the arrangements supporting it, their application, or the purpose itself. An arrangement can achieve its purpose while imposing an objectionable requirement. Examine the grounds for the requirement as well as whether it is effective.