Framework sections

The framework / 02

Principles

The principles of Plain Ethics are deliberately broad to apply to a wide range of situations and to allow flexible application of its set of tools. The principles are designed to guide users in reflecting about what people and organisations do, propose to do, and the reasons they provide for it. Applying the principles requires critical thinking and care in both description and judgement.

Identify what is being assessed and for what purpose

  • Identify the conduct, proposed action, practice, arrangement, judgement or response being considered, and the question being asked about it.
  • Specify whether the assessment is about a person, a group, a practice or an organisational arrangement.
  • Identify the applicable requirements and criteria and any disagreement or misunderstanding about their meaning or relevance (disagreements and misunderstandings are particularly important to fully explore situations).

Identify whether arrangements for conduct are in place and, if so, what they are and how they operate

  • Identify any codes, policies, agreements, or other arrangements that establish expectations for conduct.
  • Establish whom they apply to, what they require or permit, and where judgment is required for their application.

Use clear concepts and look at their relationships

  • Understand what the concepts mean and how they connect with each other.
  • Consider which descriptions fit the situation best and what supports their application: the same conduct can have several appropriate descriptions, each with different implications for the overall assessment of the situation.

Take circumstances into account

  • Consider the participants' abilities, knowledge, intentions and attitudes, the choices available, and the circumstances in which they acted (or would act).
  • Include other information, such as time, resources, incentives, and support available to them.

Compare the situation to standard cases and common failures

  • Compare the use of the concepts in this situation with their ordinary uses.

    Compare the different ways in which things could go wrong.

  • Think about what changes when a relevant feature of the situation changes (such as knowledge, a relationship, available resources, alternatives, the manner of acting or subsequent conduct).

    Explain why these changes matter.

Explain judgements, choices, and responses and give reasons for them

  • Explain the assessment and any proposed choice or response.

    Connect the descriptions and circumstances with your conclusion.

    Specify what the response seeks to achieve and why it is appropriate.

  • Consider objections and alternatives and explain any qualification to your assessment.
  • Give reasons for revising or retaining your assessment when further information or a different appreciation of the situation is considered.

The principles are guides only and need to be applied flexibly.