Framework sections

The framework / 05

Connections

Concepts connect through the elements they share. A duty and a right can involve the same required conduct. A justification and an excuse can address the same act while answering different questions about it. The connections below specify those relationships and illustrate their use.

A duty specifies conduct owed to someone. Obligation is the broader requirement to act or refrain from acting; accountability is being answerable to someone for a matter. The same conduct can involve all three.

01 / Connections

Values, principles and duties

A value can be expressed in a principle whose application to a situation involves a particular duty. Explaining the connection requires showing how the principle gives effect to the value and how it gives rise to a duty involving the people and circumstances concerned.

Example

A commitment to fair treatment requires assessing applicants against transparent, relevant criteria. Under the agreed selection procedure, the panel owes applicants an assessment against those criteria.

Connected pattern

Someone values something; a principle expresses that value; applying the principle in these circumstances supports a duty to act in a particular way.

02 / Connections

Rights and duties

A right to require a specific conduct from a role or body corresponds to a duty owed by that person or body.

Example

Under the review arrangements, the panel owes a duty to the applicant to give reasons for its decision. The applicant is entitled to receive those reasons from the panel.

Connected pattern

Someone is under an obligation to someone to do or refrain from something; the person is entitled to require that conduct from them.

03 / Connections

Interests and duties

An interest can give a reason for a duty to protect or promote it. An interest held by the person bound by the duty can also interfere with proper fulfillment of the duty. These connections identify whose interest is involved and how it bears on the required conduct.

Examples

Students' interest in understanding the value of their own work helps explain a tutor's duty to provide useful feedback. A selection panel member's financial interest in a candidate's business may interfere with impartial assessment of the candidate.

Connected patterns

Someone owes a duty that protects another person's interest. Someone has an interest that may interfere with performing their duty.

04 / Connections

Promises and reliance

By promising, someone undertakes to another person to act in a particular way. The other person may arrange their affairs based on that undertaking.

Example

Miriam promises to cover Peter's shift. Peter books an appointment on that basis.

Connected pattern

Someone promises someone that they will do something; the recipient relies on its being done when deciding what to do themselves.

05 / Connections

Where permission is a person's to give, their consent can provide it within the act, purpose and conditions agreed. The adequacy and scope of consent determine what it permits.

Example

Amelia agrees to an interview being recorded for the HR team's analysis. Sharing the recording with a different audience would require further permission.

Connected pattern

Someone consents to an act or arrangement under specified conditions; the permission given extends to what falls under that agreement.

06 / Connections

Intention and consequences

An act connects what someone means to do with what follows from doing it. Consequences may be sought, foreseen without being sought, or unforeseen.

Example

A manager changes a meeting time to include colleagues located overseas, anticipating that the meeting time will now conflict with other meetings that a colleague from the local team is required to attend.

Connected pattern

Someone intends to do something; doing it brings about a consequence that they sought, foresaw or did not foresee.

07 / Connections

Interests, harm and benefit

An interest identifies what is at stake for someone in how a matter is handled. An act can harm or benefit that person in a respect relevant to that interest. Specify the person, the interest, and what changes for them because of the act.

Example

A colleague has an interest in keeping her home address private. Another employee circulates it to the whole team without her agreement. The disclosure damages her privacy.

Connected pattern

Someone has an interest in how a matter is handled; an act harms or benefits that person in a respect relevant to that interest.

08 / Connections

Care and precautions

Care connects attention to people's needs and circumstances with assistance and precautions suited to them. Understanding what matters to the person helps determine what assistance or precaution would be appropriate.

Example

An organiser asks about a participant's access needs, discusses suitable options and arranges a route that enables participation.

Connected pattern

Someone attends to another person's needs and circumstances, and acts to support them or protect them from harm.

09 / Connections

Justification and excuse

A justification is about the acceptability of conduct, while an excuse is about the responsibility for it. As always, circumstances will be relevant to both assessments.

Example

A fire in the building is a justification for a facilitator interrupting a speech. An employee misses a required meeting because they lose consciousness without warning and are taken to hospital. This excuses their failure to attend.

Connected pattern

Giving reasons can confirm the acceptability of an act, while pointing out circumstances can help qualify a person's responsibility for what they did or failed to do.

Mitigation gives reasons or points out circumstances to explain why a less severe assessment or response would be appropriate. Specify whether those reasons apply to the seriousness of untoward conduct, the person's responsibility, or the response to the conduct.

10 / Connections

Responsibility and accountability

An accountability relationship can require a person charged with specific work to carry out to give an account of that work to someone else. The work and the recipient of the account need to be specified separately.

Example

The project lead is responsible for allocating and monitoring tasks and is answerable to the committee for the allocation.

Connected pattern

Someone is charged with doing something and is answerable to someone for carrying it out.

11 / Connections

Responsibility and blame

Blaming someone holds them responsible for untoward conduct. What they did, why it is considered reprehensible, and the circumstances surrounding the action help determine whether and how far blame is appropriate.

Example

A project lead knowingly takes credit for another person's analysis. Another staff member who, by mistake or out of ignorance, later attributes the work to the Project Lead may be considered responsible for the misattribution, but in a different way.

Connected pattern

Someone did something considered reprehensible; the circumstances of the action can either reinforce or reduce (or be irrelevant to) the blame directed at them.

12 / Connections

Apology and making amends

An apology can acknowledge a wrong and contribute to making amends. Further action may be needed to put it right. You should consider the apology to understand if and what further action would be required.

Example

An organisation representative apologises at a public event for the release of a report for omitting a key contributor's name on the event program. The organisation corrects the event program and offers an updated version.

Connected pattern

Someone apologises to someone for something; action is taken to make amends or address the negative impact on the person.

13 / Connections

Praise and gratitude

Praise recognises something good in a person's conduct. Gratitude expresses appreciation for a benefit received through their contribution. The same act can be the subject of both responses, depending on the circumstances.

Example

The manager praises Sandra's patience in helping a colleague. The colleague is grateful for the help received; the manager is also grateful to Sandra for taking over a task that would otherwise be left to her to complete.

Connected pattern

Someone praises a person for their conduct; someone is grateful to that person for a benefit received through it.

14 / Connections

Expectations and duties

An expectation of conduct and a duty can involve the same person and action while their sources may differ. A manager's expectation may express a duty already established by a role, undertaking or other ethical ground; it may also ask for more than the duty requires or conflict with it.

Connected pattern

Someone expects an action of someone; a duty requires that person to do or refrain from specified conduct.

Example

A manager expects a reviewer to approve a report today. The reviewer has a duty to check its accuracy.

You should distinguish between the presence of an expectation, a duty, and whether either or both are fulfilled.

15 / Connections

Expected consequences and incentives

Expectations as to the consequence of an action will impact their choice. An expected reward or avoided cost can be an incentive to act. Incentive can impact on choices, such as other considerations like duties, values etc.

Connected pattern

Someone considers an action; they expect a particular consequence if they take it; they take that consequence into account alongside other considerations.

Example

A staff member considers raising an issue with their manager but expects to lose desirable work if they do. The expectation about work allocation can discourage raising the issue even though organisational policy aims to make reporting issues easier for staff.

Examine the expectations that can apply to the situation and what actually influences the person.

16 / Connections

Work, ability and support

Assigned work, authority, and ability can involve the same person and task: a person with all the required abilities may still require support in order to complete their work.

Connected pattern

Someone is allocated to a task; carrying it out adequately requires particular abilities, conditions and resources; specified people provide or control those conditions, and may need to provide or give access to those so the person may complete the task.

Example

Alexandra is assigned to mentor six colleagues. She has the skills and authority to arrange meetings. Her manager, Benjamin, must also make time available within her workload to allow for the mentoring activities.

Case variation

Benjamin removes the time allowance for mentoring activities while expecting that Alexandra will continue the mentoring activities. This changes the conditions for carrying out the work.

Prospectively, ask what would be needed to successfully complete the mentoring activities and who would provide it. Retrospectively, ask what was available, what was done and what alternative courses of action were available. Identify to whom the person is answerable for the work.

17 / Connections

Interests, dependence and independent judgement

A person may have a duty to review an aspect of the work of someone on whom they depend. The relationship can interfere with the duty even when the person intends to judge fairly.

Connected pattern

Someone must evaluate another person's conduct; that person may have control over an interest of the person conducting the evaluation; arrangements could limit inappropriate pressure or conflict between duty and interest.

Example

A consultant must evaluate a manager's work, but that manager decides whether to renew the consultant's contract. Assigning the evaluation to someone whose contract the manager does not control can reduce pressure on the evaluator.

Independence must be assessed and confirmed relative to the evaluation carried out. Judging impartially requires considering the matter on relevant grounds. Independence can support impartial judgement.

18 / Connections

Promises and subsequent conduct

A promise identifies who undertakes to do what, to whom the undertaking is given, and any agreed time or conditions. Following what the person subsequently does allows us to examine whether they have fulfilled that undertaking.

Connected pattern

Someone promises someone that they will do something under agreed conditions; their subsequent conduct fulfils or fails to fulfil that undertaking.

Example

A firm promises each junior employee one hour of mentoring every fortnight during their first three months. It assigns mentors but provides only an introductory meeting during that period. The promised fortnightly mentoring has not been provided.

19 / Connections

Duties that bear on the same matter

Duties can apply to the same matter while making different demands: their performance may interfere with one another.

Connected pattern

Someone has duties relating to a matter; the people it is owed to, and scope and circumstances of their fulfillment determine what each calls for and how they can be fulfilled.

Example

A reviewer must protect confidential information and owes a participant an explanation of their decision. A single explanation may fulfil both duties.

20 / Connections

A concern, a decision and a reply

Follow the concern across different acts: raising it, considering it, and deciding what to do in response to it. Often, different people will perform each act. You should identify who is responsible for coordinating the whole matter, including progress, communication and resolution, and to whom that role or body is answerable.

Connected pattern

Someone raises a concern with someone; a person considers that concern and decides what to do; a reply explains the decision and reasons for the decision.

Example

Helen raises a concern about workload allocation with Oscar. Oscar considers Helen's concern and the allocation, decides that it must be corrected, and explains the decision to Helen. The correction, checks, and communication to staff are then carried out.

Case variation

Careful examination shows that the workload allocation was misunderstood. Oscar explains why there is no need to correct the allocation, but that a note may need to be added to avoid any misunderstanding. A duty to consider the concern is not an obligation to agree with it.

A concern is sent by email to a manager. An acknowledgement provides evidence of receipt. A well-written reply can be evidence of due consideration of the concern. However, whether the concern was adequately considered requires understanding of the presence of a duty, accountability, or responsibility.

21 / Connections

Raising concerns and protecting people

Raising a concern can expose someone to harm or disadvantage through victimisation. A manager may need to take steps to protect the person raising the concern.

Connected pattern

Someone faces a risk because of their involvement in a concern that was raised; a role or body is charged with taking suitable precautions, responding to warning signs, and taking steps to limit any negative consequences to the person.

Example

A manager is assigned to review changes in Nicole's work allocation after she raises a concern, including changes that could reduce her opportunities. Any concern raised about the manager's involvement in the matter would require an appropriately impartial channel.

Retaliation means disadvantaging or threatening someone as reprisal for their involvement in a matter. A later disadvantage may have another explanation. Both would need to be kept separate, or a clear connection established.

Protection needs can continue after a case closes and can extend to other people involved in a matter, e.g., witnesses. An allegation being unsubstantiated does not by itself justify disadvantage to the person who raised it. If required, their conduct in raising the concern should be assessed on its own grounds (e.g., possibility of vexatious complaint).

22 / Connections

Fair process and responses to wrongdoing

Fairness in handling a matter depends on how people can contribute to the process or answer to claims made about them, what evidence is considered during the process, who decides, the grounds for making the decision, and how the outcome is explained. Fairness in the outcome is assessed by examining what is decided or done to those affected, in particular compared to other people in similar situations.

Connected pattern

Someone examines a matter affecting people; relevant claims and evidence are considered; an authorised person reaches a conclusion, explains it, and determines an appropriate response.

Example

Two employees receive different responses to apparently similar behaviour because one had a relevant excuse. This difference can be justified if the grounds are relevant and adequately supported.

A response can recognise appropriate conduct, impose a penalty, make amends, protect someone, correct an arrangement or prevent recurrence. Where wrongdoing is established, you should assess its seriousness, the person's responsibility, the affected people's views, and the purpose of the proposed response.