Describing what someone did is a critical part of evaluating conduct. Different descriptions can direct attention to different aspects of the same situation, perhaps with consequences for how we will assess it.
The statement below articulates three elements: person ('someone'), doing ('did'), and action ('something'). Obviously, this statement requires you to identify who did it (person) and what they did (action). The 'doing' is what connects the person to a type of conduct. This is a very simple pattern, but agreeing on this type of statement, in particular with the person identified in the statement, may be very difficult and require substantial investigation, discussion, and reflection. There may be many ways to describe what was done and, in some situations, agreement may only be reached about very general descriptions to start with.
Insofar as we want to give a fair description of the conduct, each part of the statement may need qualification:
XPerson
- Who was involved, and what part did each person play?
- What did their role or obligations require of them?
- What strengthens or reduces their responsibility?
didDoing
- Did they act deliberately, carelessly, accidentally, or under pressure?
- What did they know and intend, and what choices did they have?
AAction
- Does the description adequately say what they did?
- What makes the action wrong or objectionable in these circumstances?
- What might make it right, permissible, or reasonable?
- Does the action express or conflict with a relevant value?
These are three ways of questioning the attribution of an action to a person.
You can see how these questions connect a description of the action with the assessment of the action and the person’s responsibility.
For example, Catherine is blamed for disclosing sensitive information to a colleague who no longer has a need to know following a change of role. Catherine had not been told about the change. Would it be fair simply to say “Catherine disclosed sensitive information to someone with no need to know” or “Catherine committed a privacy breach” without mentioning these circumstances?
You could vary the questions on what makes them 'even more responsible' (aggravating factors), or on what makes the conduct particularly reprehensible (condemnable), or again how the conduct was actually justified. This model leads us to look at two key aspects of the action, responsibility and reprehensibility, and asks: How responsible are they for this action? How reprehensible was it? From description of the conduct, we have now transitioned to evaluation of the conduct.